Confidentiality and consent stanford childrens health. The right of minors to confidentiality and informed consent. Important call 111 for advice if youre worried about a baby or child. The wspa ethics committee is frequently asked about confidentiality issues related to minors between 18 years of age. It is important to always be honest with adolescent patients about the possibility that their insurance company billing may violate their privacy.
Respecting patient confidentiality is an essential part of good care. Only in a setting of trust can a patient share the private. The right of minors to confidentiality and informed consent pedro. In exchange for a small monthly fee you can download and read all of the books offered in our catalogue on any device mobile, tablet, ereader with web navigator or pc.
It is mostly just info i need to tell him that might affect a diagnosis and it might lead to a. Confidentiality is both a patient s right and a doctor s duty. Physicians who treat minors have an ethical duty to the developing autonomy of minor patients by involving children in making decisions about their health. A duty of confidentiality is owed to all children and. If an individuals services record pertains in whole or in part to referral, diagnosis or treatment of substance use disorders, providers shall disclose information only according to applicable federal regulations see 42 cfr part 2, confidentiality of alcohol and drug abuse patient records. This includes making efforts to obtain the minor s. The trust that comes with confidentiality facilitates the patient s describing often very private matters. Cuomos proposal seeks confidentiality for minors with h. This guide is dedicated to addressing health provider concerns about. A confidentiality agreement between a patient and his doctor eases any uncertainty in the part of the former to be completely honest to the latter, for the fear that his behavior will be reported against him. Normally, the parent or guardian will instruct the health care provider and give or refuse consent on the childs or teenagers behalf. Patients 18 years or older can consent for their own confidential health. Once children have reached the teen years, they are old enough to be afforded a degree of doctor patient confidentiality. Children and teenagers who are capable of making their own decisions have the same rights to privacy and confidentiality as adults.
The safeguarding of patient confidentiality is a fundamental principle of medical ethics which dates back to the hippocratic oath. You ought not deceive or mislead patients who desire to understand medical information about themselves. The age by which you have automatic confidentiality. There is an embedded expectation of responsibility for the patient as the physicians confidant. Patient consent should generally be obtained before testing for drugs or abuse, but may be waived when the patient s mental status or judgment is impaired. For minors, there is a special doctor patient confidentiality in place. The apas recommendation on tobacco, alcohol and other drugs, is. Doctor patient confidentiality is a precept of adolescent medicine.
The concept of doctorpatient confidentiality derives from english common law and is codified in many states statutes. The right of a mature minor to consent to medical care without prior parental consent has been recognized in many states 4. Does doctorpatient confidentiality apply to minors. In this lesson, we will learn about confidentiality in the medical care. The only way this can be achieved is through private consultations and examinations. Doctors and therapists have what is called doctor patient confidentiality anything told to the doctor or therapist is protected by that right. The adolescent health guide is designed for healthcare providers, social workers. Article information, pdf download for the right of minors to confidentiality and informed.
In ohio, is there a doctor patient confidentiality law for minors. Consent and confidentiality laws in minnesota minnesota. Pdf confidentiality and treatment decisions of minor clients. Confidentiality is essential to safeguard a patient s dignity, privacy and autonomy and extends after death. A case study exploring doctorpatient confidentiality. Monroe county medical society practice management resources. What is the law about doctor patient confidentiality for minors. Beginning with this issue, and continuing every other month, the apa monitor on psychology will feature ethics rounds, in which apas ethics office will answer questions about the ethical issues psychologists most commonly face. I might say, everything you tell me without a parent in the room is confidential. Consent may come from the patient or the parentguardian, depending on the patients age. Navigating ethics of physicianpatient confidentiality. What is the law about doctor patient confidentiality for.
When do minors in therapy have a right to confidentiality. Bundle one volumes one two and three doctor patient confidentiality. Our catalogue includes more than 1 million books in several languages. Confidentiality is an agreement between a doctor and a patient that information dis cussed during or. For example, if you are treating a 14yearold client, do the clients parents have the right to obtain your records without the clients consent. Hi, my friend 16 stayed over at a family friends house a couple of weekends ago and ended up experimenting with a substance for the. A case study exploring doctor patient confidentiality when the patient is a minor. Navigating the complexities of privacy in the adolescent gyn patient can be difficult and frustrating. As aforementioned, without complete, unbounded honesty, the treatment process may be more difficult or, most importantly, inaccurate. Confidentiality is often an important aspect of a trusting therapeutic relationship. Doctors may disclose personal information without breaching duties of confidentiality under certain circumstances, such as when the disclosure is of overall benefit to a patient who lacks capacity to consent. With the minors consent, a physician may examine, prescribe for, and treat such minor patient. Without the trust that confidentiality brings, children and young people might not seek medical care and advice, or they might not tell you all the facts needed to provide good care. Hhs hipaa home for professionals faq 2092can a minor childs doctor talk to the childs parent about the patient.
As a result, they either lie to their doctors or simply omit information be. Without the assurance of confidentiality, patients are unable to trust their doctors with the truth. Understanding minor consent and confidentiality in colorado adolescent an provider toolkit scho ol bas e d h eal th c ar e col o rad o a ssoci a t io n fo r. We need to balance the needs and legal rights of our patient with those of her parents. In general, physicians honor the privacy of adolescents unless there is evidence that the. Doctor patient confidentiality is extremely important but rules of confidentiality can change when a minor is the patient. Each doctor creates a script to establish confidentiality. Parents consent to a confidentiality agreement between the minor and the healthcare provider. When minors request confidential services, physicians should encourage them to involve their parents. Confidential health care for minors american medical association. Adolescent confidentiality and electronic health records acog. Write a letter to the doctor here to ask to look at your records. It is based on ethics, not law, and goes at least as far back as the roman hippocratic oath taken by physicians.
My goal is to persuade my patients to disclose the information themselves. Learn how confidentiality laws apply to minors and how to discuss privacy concerns with younger clients. Four positions regarding confidentiality with minors exist. Doctorpatient confidentiality is a precept of adolescent medicine. The aap recommends that providers develop written guidelines that conform to the laws of consent for the treatment of minors, including specific information on financial billing, parental notification, and patient confidentiality for unaccompanied minors aap committee on pediatric emergency medicine, 2003. A minor waives the doctor patient privilege, if heshe commences a personal injury or malpractice lawsuit and the minor s health is in question. Automatic confidentiality automatic confidentiality means that unless youre likely to be seriously harmed or your life is at risk, a doctor or other health professional is required by law to keep what you say private, even from your parents or guardian. I looked on a few sites but did not get a direct answer. Guidance for doctors on providing care for children and young people from birth to.
Confidential health care for minors code of medical ethics opinion 2. Doctorpatient confidentiality is extremely important but rules of confidentiality can change when a minor is the patient. Many of these minors selfmanage complex conditions with little parental involvement, and perhaps should, in some cases, also have the right to confidentiality if deemed appropriate by the doctor, the minor and the parent. Article in aap news on minor consent state laws this article outlines the consent laws for minors by state, how to interpret them, and where to access them. However, there are certain situations where only the minor can consent to the disclosure of health information. The section on confidentiality stresses how important it is that children and. A confidential relationship between physician and patient is essential for the free flow of information necessary for sound medical care. The federal confidentiality statute and regulations that apply. In situations where a minor patient is being treated for a mental health disorder and a substance abuse disorder, additional laws may be applicable. Below are some resources to help understand the consent and confidentiality. When the patient is a minor, ordinarily the parent, guardian, or custodian is authorized to give written consent to disclosure of the childs health information. Confidentiality is an important ethical and legal duty for doctors, but it is not absolute. Pdf issues relating to confidentiality and consent for physical and mental health treatment with minor. Since your advice to patients is based on medical information given to you in the context of your professional relationship, you have an obligation to preserve patient confidentiality.
Reassessing minor breaches of confidentiality journal. Doctor patient confidentiality is the cornerstone of the relationship between any medical professional and the patients for whom they care. We have attached a leaflet for you to download, should you require. Nhs codes of confidentiality and information security. Generally the right to consent entitles the patient to confidentiality. The confidentiality between patient and doctor has long been observed and was codified in the first ama code of medical ethics 4.
Understanding confidentiality and minor consent in california. Confidential health care for minors american medical. I also want to promote healthy communication between the patient and parents. However, there are situations where confidentiality is not in the best interest of the minor.
In general parents are considered the personal representative of minors and under hipaa they are entitled to their personal health information phi. Gauge your knowledge of this confidentiality as well as the age for majority by using the quiz. When a minor has the right to consent, a provider generally may not disclose the minor s health care information to anyone, including the minor s parents or guardians, without the. A confidentiality pledge advocates that patients and physicians openly discuss the ways patients want their information treated. Unlike financial harm, a loss of trust between patient and doctor can be much harder to quantify or repair. Do minors in new york state have doctorpatient confidentiality. Understandiing minor consent and confidentiality in colorado cde.
Understandiing minor consent and confidentiality in colorado. Confidentiality and the adolescent patient african journals online. Parent doctor parent patient doctor patient doctor 5. How the law protects confidential services for young people depends on their age whether a patient is a minor under 18 years or an adult 18 years or older, and whether the patient can legally consent to their own care. Teenagers, health care the law a guide to the law on minors rights in new york state by jessica feierman, donna lieberman, anna schissel, rebekah diller, jaemin kim and yuehru chu.
Thats the general rule but like every legal rule how we deal with the myriad of exceptio. I might be going to the doctor soon and there is something i need to tell him and talk to him about but i do not want him to tell my mother quite yet in case it is nothing. Receiving disclosures of a personal nature from physicians may put the patient in an awkward position. Minors access to confidential health care in pennsylvania. Guide on the disclosure of confidential information. It is different from doctor patient privilege, which is a legal concept. At the doctor s discretion, the childs consent as well as confidentiality can be sidestepped. Ending the patient physician relationship sample letter. Pediatricians need to become familiar with issues related to minor consent and confidentiality to ensure the protection of their adolescent patients rights.
271 901 967 303 1186 138 1623 1214 1165 249 333 1174 661 1426 367 819 845 134 1608 198 1089 944 379 1098 1294 1100 76 760 1366 1297 95 1184 1311